AdmiralMemo, if you were the person that told you you're stupid then Dutch guy has made an error (meaning well of course) because people with depression aren't stupid for having said that to themselves. Given the timing of Memo's first comment I would say it's likely the person he isn't naming is A...

Personally, I've always been far more concerned about quality than quantity when it comes to length of games (or any media for that matter). If a game strikes me as being 'not worth it' on account of length, it's because I consider it to be poorly paced as a result - which can just as easily mean a ...

The way I see it now the end result will be Trump v. Clinton. And Trump just gets trounced in the actual election. Thing is, everyone was saying Trump would get trounced during the pre--presidential-election election back when it started. Now it's looking like he's going to win that. I don't think ...

Triskaidekaphobia, perhaps?

My problem is that it had the main character be a complete ass for no real reason. Yes, his reaction was similar to the one he had during the first copy process. But, if anything, that makes me feel like it makes less sense. He started throwing a tantrum despite it being the same thing as the first...

Just finished watching Alex play SOMA. It was a really interesting narrative, though it feels like the medium was... poor-suited for telling the story. Mostly because it felt like the story had to take long breaks just to be a game (not the puzzles, but the slowly moving between places, just becaus...

This is why I also add the "choice" element to the list as well. It can be small. It can be as simple as picking up a rock or not. It doesn't even have to affect the outcome. But I believe that the element of some sort of choice needs to exist for it to be called a "game." The o...

On the other hand, by refusing the label you're instead limiting the creative potential of the medium in general. All you're essentially arguing is that we should find a new name for the entire medium that we currently call 'video games' because you want to use the term 'video games' to refer to a ...

So why make the distinction at all? Beyond the pedantic rationalization, I think trying to label any "virtual experience" as a game stymies their creative exploration. How many horror games have been made with arbitrary "find the keys" and "puzzle locks" crammed in to ...

I must admit that I was hoping you'd pick up at least one myself. I should reuse the necromancer role at some point so it can have another chance at demonstrating how powerful it really is The problem with the necromancer isn't that it's not powerful it's that it's inconsistently powerful. If it hi...

I'm also surprised by the sheer power level of the game (though that's not a complaint; just an observation). It was pretty unexpected for me to functionally have 3 investigators, 2 (or maybe 1.5) villain groups and a pair of secret society members as well as a roleblocker. That's a lot of power be...

Huh, and here I was preparing to break down my list of 'reasons Jamfalcon is totes a revenant' :P I figured it was my best chance, especially since Jam's ability doesn't seem like it'd have been affected by my ability. Plus, since it only worked until I did a kill, it would help if anyone tried to d...

Hey Metric, just a thought... there's always the slim possibility that there's another twist in the roles or something we're not seeing, and maybe we're both innocent and are just going at each other's throats needlessly. Just in case that's true, I'm going to follow you tonight. If you still have ...

Smeghead wrote:Well not like we got anything better to do but to vote for Another shorten

True enough

Vote: Shorten

Smeghead wrote:Well I guess there is no point in delaying this any further.

None whatsoever.

Vote: AdmiralMemo
Vote: Shorten

Jamfalcon wrote:First off, good job everyone, and thanks for trusting me yesterday.

We didn't, you just weren't the biggest threat. Tomorrow though is going to be a different matter entirely.

Jamfalcon wrote:I would just like to remind people that Metric, who keeps pushing the idea that I'm "almost certainly" undead is the one I saw Memo visit last night

Of course that's also exactly the sort of detail you'd lie about if you were the Revenant, now isn't it?

Well, the question is, is there anyone else who fits the bill better? None that I can see. The only other wereweagle option was Jamfalcon and honestly he's almost definitely the revenant at this point. The only real reason I did the extension was in case anyone had a better idea than voting for you...

I think we should completely disregard Memo's actions; we have no way of knowing how deep the(Double/triple/quadruple/...) bluff goes. So, disregarding it all(At least for now) would probably prevent him from playing us. I dunno, watching him repeatedly goozle himself is a little amusing :P Anyway,...

With all the shorten votes bouncing around I'm going to through out a vote: kapol, in case Smeghead and Robo don't get back in time.

You're the one who said: It also seems highly unlikely that the pack leader wouldn't have an ability beyond 'nightkill' I did. Although you'll notice that 'immune to faction checks' is a passive ability rather than an active one, and that there aren't many other powers it would make sense for the s...

...I was actually just about to post realizing that Jam's ability is likely not true Ah, but see that brings up a problem for you. Because if Jam's ability is fabricated, then it raises the question: who has the priority 3 ability? Korvys had Priority 0, Duckay had a Priority 2 ability and with her...

I don't recall a 'godfather' ever being immune to investigation. That's generally what they're known for being . There is also the fact Snorsh specified investigation abilities are reliable, not that they were accurate. Which would imply that if there was anyone who had an ability that said they re...

Does revenants die if the necromancer does? Memo said earlier that he could still win if he died as long as the person he raised survived to the end; which suggests they don't. Do Jam or Metric have any information to give us? Well, something's been bothering me since we lynched Duckay. Specificall...

Priority number one right now is that Robo and Smeghead need to find out from Mono_Snorsh if their telepathy ability would let them know if the other cultist changed faction or not.

Personally, I think that keeping Memo alive is better for the mafia than it is for the town. Consider that Smeghead and Robo don't just need the town to win, they need the town to win and still both be alive when that happens. This means that eliminating a killing role is by far their highest prior...