I gave my reasons, Volafortis. You can't keep saying "There's no evidence to go on!" and ignoring all the discussions and arguments the rest of us are having. I suspect some of the people on my list are mafia. Unless some other evidence comes along, it seems logical to me to start testing ...

Yeah, I don't think he did anything yesterday to draw the mafia's attention. In fact, he unintentionally helped their cause by supporting the lynch of a Townie. If I was a suspicious, paranoid bastard, I might think that there are indeed several wrong 'uns among those who voted for Ptangmatik yester...

Well, this is an... ENTIRELY NORMAL game, but that doesn't always mean there are extra killing roles. No, why Memo, that poor gentle soul, he wasn't supposed to die till day three. Now really... Did you not pay attention to what happened to Ptangmatik? Talking like that can get a guy lynched around ...

There haven't really been enough consecutive No Lynch votes to call it a bandwagon. Most people just didn't want to lynch too early. You know what? A day 1 lynch is better than no day one lynch, and being a cannibal is as good intel as we can reasonably expect at this stage. Correction: it was the b...

True, we wouldn't want to be a rude angry vengeful lynch mob. We'll give it a little longer for Hepheastus to check in. Since korvys reminded fish to add the player list to the OP, presumably he's seen the game has started and chosen not to post. Once again, I can only assume this is because he'll b...

Good call. There's got to be something going on here, I just can't work out what the fuck it is.

(Congratulations on turning me into a gibbering ball of paranoia with merely the power of suggestion, iamafish! )

You're not sure you buy my story that I voted for someone because said they were a cannibal? I can't speak for Duckay or Memo, but my vote was mostly for the lols. Which is why I'm sceptical, rather than just convinced you're up to something. To be fair, I probably wouldn't have paid it so much att...

Well my initial vote was clearly silly based on the roleplaying. Yes, CLEARLY you are the good guy and this is all a terrible misunderstanding. It certainly couldn't be the case that you attacked another player on Day One for reasons that, while undisclosed, can only be nefarious, and now you're ba...

Oh god, it's going to be like that time in Edinburgh all over again...

elvor wrote:Man, everyone is apparently really bloodthirsty this morning...

No, just quietly resigned to the inevitable.

Happy slightly late birthday!

I, too, liked that townsfolk. His company was soothing in these frantic, troubled modern times. Now, with his calming influence gone, I fear we must form a mob and brutally lynch suspects until the killers have been eliminated.

I would love to play in your entirely normal, vanilla game of mafia that is not at all in any way nonstandard. Hopefully this time I'll be able to check in more than once a day and not miss every vote.

So that's, what... Ptang, Duckay, Tapir, Gunner, korvys and Memo? Hmmm, that's still too many to pick out the traitors. I know some of you guys were just following the Don's lead. Ain't no way that many of us are disloyal after all Don Preacher's done for the family. I was hella amused by this. On ...

I really wasn't able to check in often enough to make much of an impact this time. :( Oh well, I'm not too unhappy with death by snoo-snoo. Well played, Duckay! (In case it wasn't clear from my in-character bit about "I've seen it happen before", in every recent game of Mafia or The Resist...

(Not touching that one...) Why, Heph? Just... why? Why risk yourself like that? And now 'fish has bought it too. We need to get our shit together. Assuming there are at least a couple more traitors still alive, we're getting ever closer to being outnumbered. If it wasn't for whoever whacked Tapir - ...

(In case it wasn't clear from my in-character bit about "I've seen it happen before", in every recent game of Mafia or The Resistance when I've got into a slanging match with someone, both of us turned out to be good guys and we lost because we were too busy going after each other. I figur...

I didn't say anything about your intentions, I didn't single ya out, I just said ya voted. Which ya did. (Dunno why , since a decision had already been reached, but ya did.) Still, I've had some experience weeding out troublemakers, and I don't know if you're the type. I mighta been tempted to think...

I figure the list of guys who jumped oh-so-fast onto that no-lynch bandwagon probably contains a traitor or two. So that's, what... Ptang, Duckay, Tapir, Gunner, korvys and Memo? *is drinking some coffee and does a spit-take* "Jumped fast on the "no-lynch" bandwagon?" Were you e...

'As much as I'd like to avoid us falling into... mob mentality-' He stopped and seemed to think about it for a second 'The other kind of mob that is.' (Whale plaid, good sir.) I figure the list of guys who jumped oh-so-fast onto that no-lynch bandwagon probably contains a traitor or two. If I was l...

Nope, you're right the first time. By this point, it's gotta be an inside job. We shoulda spent more time hunting out the traitor yesterday. We handed them a 24-carat gold opportunity on a platter. Now we're down two more loyal men - including the doc - and we're no closer to the truth. And two kill...

Oh, here it comes. Heeere it comes. Ya got a problem with me, ya gotta start making these accusations?

(I heartily recommend both The Godfather and Goodfellas. Even people who aren't keen on gangster films as a whole might enjoy The Godfather. Unless you have a phobia of brown. It's a very brown film. I am, however, shit at gangster impersonations. :D Tempted to go Mockney for comedy value, but let's...

Ooh ooh, please sir, I can I be in the Mafia? I can stick orange peel in my mouth like a pro!

Ohhhhhh man, this was so good. The opening credits, the continuity creeping back into Hustle, the... the BEEJ. The man's practically a meme all by himself.

Can't Wear Hats wrote:Cool story bro!

WHAT YOU DID THERE. I SEE IT.