Vanilla Mafia- Town Wins!!!

[Jamfalcon]

I was talking about the responses to this post:

I've already said that if you guys want me to. I will tell you guys. No one has spoken up.

Although to be fair, it was only a twenty four hour window between that post and Octo revealing allegiances of the dead players. I should also be clearer, when I say I'm somewhat confident, I mean that in the sense of maybe twenty percent more suspicious of you; if I had to bet I'd put my money on you, but I'm not entirely sold on the idea.

[TheRocket]

I've already said that if you guys want me to. I will tell you guys. No one has spoken up.

I'll reveal their orientation, but not role. That good with everyone?

House MD - Mafia
DarkAbyssKeeper - Town
ex-Luker - Mafia

And by the time I came by, this had already happened. Notice how I did not make a post in between that time? If I had been around of course I would have spoken up to say I wanted things revealed. In fact my last post was a gripe about NOT having more insight on people.

[TheRocket]

Vote: redacted

I think SilPho's reasoning is enough for me, and the fact that you are trying to lynch another townie says enough for me to get this show on the road.

[Jamfalcon]

Hence my saying "to be fair, it was only a twenty four hour window between that post and Octo revealing allegiances of the dead players." It was a part of my argument I hadn't looked at before my post, and now that I've realized that I won't hold your silence against you.

[JackSlack]

Changevote: SilPho He leapt on my suggestion fast. Classic Mafia move.

[SilPho]

Changevote: SilPho He leapt on my suggestion fast. Classic Mafia move.

My stated reasons still hold merit. That said, Jamfalcon's adamant denial of being a mafia sounds like JackSlack, and Falcon's substantial effort to divert suspicion seems oddly reminiscent of Master Gunner's behaviour... and he was a townie too.

I'm a little more interested to hear from the quiet members, iamafish in particular seems very quiet. It just feels as though the people involved in this current discussion aren't threats. Leaving the mafia to sit back and watch us pick on each other.

[aeric90]

I'm with SilPho. Although I'm very suspicious of both JackSlack and TheRocket's sudden aggressiveness and the former's somewhat erratic vote.I am curious why we haven't heard from anyone else.

I'm holding off voting until then.

[TheRocket]

Wait, you're suspicious of my aggression and vote? I mean, If I said I was highly suspicious of you and basically telling the town to lean in and lynch you, would you not be a little on edge? I'm voting for Jam because Silphos reasoning is the best we have yet, and because that mother lover tried to lead the town in a lynch against me! That's enough to make anyone say HARUMPH.

If anyone has any better reasoning or suspicion for anyone else, I'd love to hear it. As it stands I don't REALLY want to lynch JamFalcon because if he isn't mafia people are going to look at ME now just as I was telling him they would do to him if you lynched me. I guess I'm really hoping a townsperson has SOME sort of insight to mafia here.

[Tapir12]

Hmm.. I'm really torn. I came into Day 3 with a suspicion, but I'm starting to doubt myself.

I may as well say my suspicion has been on SilPho. He joined the first lynch late (mafia) and jumped on the second lynch early (not mafia). Plus he has been more than happen to post a lot in day 2 about food and llamas to make himself seem active and engaged without really contributing much.

However, on the other hand, he was pushing for revealing the orientations of the dead and has been contributing more worthwhile content today than he was yesterday. So now for now I'm undecided.

[SilPho]

Personally, I can't decide whether my initial suspicions of Jamfalcon are founded enough for a vote or whether we take a shot in the dark and aim for iamafish.

You know what, screw it.
Vote: iamafish.

[aeric90]

Okay. That vote is ridiculous. iamafish suspected SilPho after he targeted MasterGunner and he also commented on the lack of affiliation thread. Other than his silence that vote is baseless.

Vote: SilPho.

(edit to bold the vote)

[SilPho]

iamafish suspected SilPho after he targeted MasterGunner

Er... what?

[aeric90]

Sorry... not SilPho. Kapol.

[octopimpostor]

2 votes for SilPho

[SilPho]

Good point about iamafish, Aeric. Some proof is better than the random guess I first took.

Change Vote: None

By the way, should we be suspicious of Rocket's edited redaction of her original vote for Jamfalcon?

[TheRocket]

Uhm, I though that was how we were supposed to change our votes. =/

[aeric90]

In the light of SilPho's vote retraction:

Change Vote: JackSlack

I'm going with my suspicions.

[JackSlack]

I'm sticking with Silpho. Aeric, look at how quickly Silpho leapt on my suggestion. That's classic Mafia. You don't want to suggest, it looks suspicious, but you do want to push any non-mafia lynch. It's exactly what I'd do were I mafia.

[TheRocket]

*sigh* Jack Slack has the best reason for a vote here imho. Even though if I now vote for Silpho, it looks as if I did the same thing which is leaping on your suggestion. But I am at a loss here. None of us have solid evidence for a vote, just wild suspicion and speculation.

[JackSlack]

*sigh* Jack Slack has the best reason for a vote here imho. Even though if I now vote for Silpho, it looks as if I did the same thing which is leaping on your suggestion. But I am at a loss here. None of us have solid evidence for a vote, just wild suspicion and speculation.

Has e'er there ever been a Mafia game that operated on more than wild suspicion and speculation?

[aeric90]

Well here's a bit better evidence maybe. I read JackSlack's post from earlier about the lynching of HouseMD which I missed. Which is making me second guess my vote.

Out of everyone left only 2 people did not vote for HouseMD's lyching: TheRocket and Tapir12

Now voting in the group and eliminating a silent member would be a great way to ward off suspicion but Kapol and ex-Lurker did not vote either.

Might seem like I'm all over the place here but there's a lot of llama related stuff to filter out.

Change Vote: No Vote
FOS: TheRocket and Tapir12

Sorry JackSlack, I believe you now.

[Dutch guy]

I don't know what to do. I'm completely clueless right now

*bangs head against wall*

[aeric90]

If we think the evidence is sound enough I'd say we pick one of the two and lynch. If they're not mafia, and not the serial killer, the SK can pop the other and end the game. If they are the SK or town then at least we'll know who's mafia for the next round.

And if they are the SK or town I'll likely be dead overnight anyways.

[SilPho]

I'm sticking with Silpho. Aeric, look at how quickly Silpho leapt on my suggestion. That's classic Mafia. You don't want to suggest, it looks suspicious, but you do want to push any non-mafia lynch. It's exactly what I'd do were I mafia.

Your "suggestion" was a random number generator. And I didn't even vote for Jamfalcon, I only provided a point to consider for discussion. That point was then countered by him, at which point he voiced his suspicions of Tapir, JackSlack and Rocket. Only two of them have so far claimed to be townies.

And where is iamafish, anyway?

[TheRocket]

I'm unsure why I am suspicious?