AdmiralMemo wrote:0-3
I suck at this game, but at least I had fun and it felt fair this time.
I watched your drafting, here's my thoughts:
-Taking a Citadel over another two goblin options seemed bad
-Since you were so heavy aggro, taking the vampire might have been better than the child.
-Since you were going practically mono-goblin, taking the Obelisk of Urd would have been VALUE. Thanks for not taking it though, I got it =P
-With the Urd, taking the enforcer would have been even more value than a green card you weren't going to play.
-When you take Generator servant, I think you have to ask what you're generating in to. Miner's bane might have been better.
-Since you were mono-red with no second colour choice, taking the blue rare was probably bad. You had a Satyr and Ranger's guile as options, which could have comboed well with the Phytotitan.
-Again not taking a goblin, probably should've taken the Restock or Titanic Growth
-Taking a Mind Rot over the Miner's Bane was probably also a bad idea.
-Taking a leeching sliver over a sideboard card is probably bad.
-Taking another Phytotitan would have done well with green plan.
-Taking Covenant of Blood over another Scrapyard was probably a bad idea.
-Taking another titanic growth was an option.
-Living totem would have been good in the next pack
-Could have taken another Urd, though maybe not as valuable with the lesser amount of Goblins. Could have taken a Ranger's Guile though.
-At this point taking the spirit was right, but the denizen could have been good in another plan.
-Another Titanic Growth went past. probably the same one.
Cliff notes:
-Could have had a pretty damn good goblin deck with two Urds.
-You passed AMAZING green for low-end black.
I'm sure my drafting is just as bad, but keep in mind this is a post-hoc judgement, it's much easier to say what someone should have done than do it yourself.
If you don't appreciate the criticism, let me know. If you do, good.