Postby RoomKeyNinja » 05 Aug 2008, 14:01
Some random thoughts. I tend to think it's important to weigh in when I care for a video so long as I actually analyze what I don't like about it, which is helpful instead of just insulting. This video might grow on me, but I think it's suffering from two marks against it in terms of winning over LLR forum members.
1) The 'huh' factor. I think this is the big one. If I'd seen this as a random link in youtube from a friend, I probably would have just kind of shrugged it off as mildly amusing. However, seeing it on the LRR site is very much like ordering a cheeseburger and being presented with a pizza. You might like both cheeseburgers and pizza, but you are going to be disorientated by the unexpectedness, which will reduce your enjoyment of the pizza somewhat. Of course, the metaphor isn't exact, since we don't 'order' anything, but it's just a comment how on how, regardless of what the video was or was not, sheer surprise can sometimes lower the enjoyment.
2) On the 'high-brow' 'low-brow' argument, I believe that material CAN rise above it's subject matter. Monty Python, Kids in the Hall, Saturday Night Live, have all done very silly skits about base functions, that are still sophisticated and clever. That being said, I don't believe this video did that. In essence, it's combining pop culture reference of skeletor, throw in a penis, and the classic frat joke of seeing another man's dick being somehow scarring psychologically. I'll admit it's WELL written, from a musical stand-point, but I don't see anything particularly clever about it. There isn't amazing turns of phrase in the lyrics, it's just musically amusing.
That being said, as always, the production professionalism continues to rise. It was executed well, and it's nice to see the team experimenting. This isn't a video intended for me, but such is life. I'll nod and get in on the next one.
Also, yes, I'd rather watch this video than half the ones that are made by multi-million dollars bands.
Is eternally grateful to Misty for this .gif
Also plotting how to destroy Bill, as all Ninjas should